Saturday, August 13, 2016

The Truth About 22 Veteran Suicides A Day


 on June 2, 2015

While the suicide rate among veterans from operations Iraqi Freedom and Enduring Freedom is still too high, it’s not 22 a day.
There is a statistic that has been widely quoted in the veteran community that highlights an estimated 22 veterans a day are committing suicide. It is a deeply troubling statistic and has galvanized the veteran movement, both from inside the military and veteran communities, and externally, to bring about a wide range of programming nationwide. The statistic, however, is widely misunderstood.
This figure — 22 veterans a day commit suicide — while widely touted by politicians, media outlets, veterans service organizations, among others, comes from the VA’s 2012 Suicide Data Report, which analyzed the death certificates of 21 states from 1999 to 2011, and often is not provided within the right context. The report itself, as cited by the Washington Post earlier this year, warned, “It is recommended that the estimated number of veterans be interpreted with caution due to the use of data from a sample of states and existing evidence of uncertainty in veteran identifiers on U.S. death certificates.” As an example, the average age of veteran suicides within the data set was nearly 60 years old, not representative of Iraq and Afghanistan veterans generation.
A more recent study, which surveyed 1.3 million veterans who were discharged between 2001 and 2007, found that “Between 2001 and 2009, there were 1650 deployed veterans and 7703 non-deployed veteran deaths. Of those, 351 were suicides among deployed veterans and 1517 were suicides among non-deployed veterans. That means over nine years, there was not quite one veteran suicide a day,” according to the Washington Post.
While veterans have a suicide rate 50% higher than those who did not serve in the military, the rate of suicide was, as the LA Times reported, “…slightly higher among veterans who never deployed to Afghanistan or Iraq, suggesting that the causes extend beyond the trauma of war.”
Coming home from war, a six-month deployment on a ship, or simply transitioning from a life in uniform to a life without one, can be difficult and the various state and federal systems set up to deal with this transition and life after military services are unable to meet the need. That is not to say these programs — the Veterans Affairs entitlement and benefit programs like medical care, the G.I. Bill, the VA Home Loan, etc. — are not helpful; they are. But, for my generation of veterans from Operation Iraqi Freedom and Operation Enduring Freedom, our suicide rate is closer to one a day and most likely to occur in the first three years of return. While this this is still very troubling, it is not 22.
Still, there are further steps needed in bridging the gap created by those who serve and those who don’t. Supporting integration back into families and communities requires robust public-private partnerships. The veterans, as well as the communities they live in, are both responsible for filling or bridging that gap, though not necessarily equally.
The challenges of adjustment and transition, post-traumatic stress, traumatic brain injuries, and physical disabilities, all need to be addressed especially as these things result in barriers to education, employment, health care, and overall individual well-being. Many of these needs are being met by a combination of different veteran-serving nonprofits and VA support. Unfortunately, there are still gaps in the system.
We in the veteran advocacy community need to tailor our programming, especially if we are in the business of preventing suicides, to respond to what we’ve learned from the data. One suicide is one suicide too many. Effective programming to help service members, veterans, and families transition to a positive life after service in their first three years home from service is a must.
Another requirement is fostering supportive community relationships for veterans, and really for all people, when life gets difficult as they surge past the age of 50. It also means that if we are serious about tackling the problem, we need to be creating, or rather shifting, programming specifically to address the needs of older veterans while maintaining preventative care for recently returned veterans.
As soldiers, sailors, airmen, and Marines, we all prided ourselves in uniform on not making the emotional decision, but the right decision. As veterans, we should have the same commitment and that means we need to act within the framework of facts — in advocacy and programming. Inadvertently, we’re preying on a well-intentioned public by citing a misleading statistic to receive financial support and that’s not right.
As veterans, we’re far more resilient than we’ve given ourselves credit for. If we do our job now, and extend a helping hand to our brothers and sisters over 50, we can decrease that suicide rate, and ensure our generation avoids despair in the future.
Stacy Bare is focused on providing programming and advocacy for veterans and others to engage in the power of time spent outdoors. He is currently working on a project, Make Adventure Not War, that will allow him to ski or climb in the various countries he deployed to during his time in service. Follow Stacy Bare on Twitter @MSSNOTDRS

PERSONAL COMMENTARY, IN RESPONSE TO THE ARTICLE ABOVE:
I don’t understand the logic, or reasoning, behind downplaying the number of Veteran suicides in this Country. The Author states, correctly, at the outset that the numbers are skewed and inaccurate based on their source(s). He then falls mistakenly into the premise that the number “22” is perhaps grossly inflated. He also seems to be comfortable with Veterans and the private sector shouldering the responsibility for fixing the “number”.
As someone with intimate experience and knowledge on this situation, I can state, unequivocally, that the fashionable number “22” is misleading, at best, but in a different direction. The “number” is too low.
Several factors come into play when talking about, reporting, and documenting Veteran suicides. For starters, the Veterans Health Administration declines to list suicide as a “cause of death” in many actual suicides. I have brought this to the attention of various levels of Professionals inside the VHA, and I am told the same thing, time after time; “We can’t automatically conclude that this Veteran’s death was an actual suicide. The “cause of death” may well have resulted from some other medical problem that was exacerbated by the use of drugs and/or alcohol; there, technically not a suicide.” With that sort of ambiguity being the standard operating procedure, the VHA can suppress the real numbers of suicides, so they don’t appear to be totally inept in dealing with the problem. The number “22” is therefore dangerously low.
“We in the veteran advocacy community need to tailor our programming, especially if we are in the business of preventing suicides, to respond to what we’ve learned from the data. One suicide is one suicide too many. Effective programming to help service members, veterans, and families transition to a positive life after service in their first three years home from service is a must.”
These three sentences are crucial to turning this suicide situation around. The first sentence should start with “The Department of Defense and the Department of Veterans Affairs need to....” It is not the duty of Veterans and Veteran Service Organizations to turn this around. Please get rid of, and cease using, this second sentence. It is a cliché, an insult to our intelligence, and an unreasonable expectation. The third sentence should probably be the title of any article addressing Veteran suicide and should directed to the aforementioned Government Agencies.
Unfortunately, it is articles like this that rely on regurgitating numbers formulated by entities that are steeped in “voodoo” accounting much like our Department of Veteran Affairs. If Veterans and Veteran Service Organizations need to advocate something, it is the need to force major change and restructuring in the way the Military transitions personnel and the way the Veterans Health Administration and Veterans Benefit Administration treats those who have served their Country. They all seem to find satisfaction in “talking the talk”; now it is time to make them “walk the walk”!

Please refer to this author’s solution, “Mandatory Military Separation Transition Program”, which can be sent to you free of charge. Contact hutch.dubosque@live.com for your copy (PDF).

Saturday, August 6, 2016

“MR. SECRETARY, TEAR DOWN THIS VA MEDICAL CENTER!”

The vast majority of buildings still in use at the VA Medical Center in Northport, NY were built in 1928-1931. There were two other major medical/psychiatric facilities here on Long Island that were built around the same time with the same architecture that are now partially, or completely, torn down. These facilities, Pilgrim State Hospital (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pilgrim_Psychiatric_Center) and the even older Kings Park Mental Institution (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kings_Park_Psychiatric_Center), were torn down due to their age, structural integrity, and environmental hazards such as asbestos, lead, and black mold. The VA Medical Center in Northport, NY, has exactly the same age, structural integrity, and environmental hazards in 95% of its buildings. So, what’s the problem, here? Why can’t the Federal Government find enough of our tax dollars to remedy the situation? This Medical Center needs to be completely razed and a new, modern Facility built in its place.
The VA Medical Center is on Federal property, nestled in the bucolic woods of Northport, NY, and is approximately 600 acres in size. There is more than enough available acreage to first construct a new medical facility, and then tear down the old one.
With a new, multi-story building of about 8-10 stories and two to four connected outbuildings, the Veteran community on Long Island will be fully and properly served. The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs has more than enough money to get this done. If you doubt they have the funding, simply check around the Nation and look at the facilities they have constructed elsewhere in the past twenty years. One of the problems in Northport seems to the Center’s Executive Director. He has never entertained the idea of such a capital improvement, because he “likes” the old architecture. Meanwhile, “Rome is burning” while he sits in his executive suite fiddling (as a famous Roman did centuries ago).
There are approximately 130,000 to 150,000 Veterans in Nassau and Suffolk Counties here in New York (http://www.osc.state.ny.us/reports/other/veterans_11_2015.pdf.) Some accounts claim lesser numbers, but not by much. At last check, it is my understanding that only a maximum of 34,000 - 28,000 Veterans (depending on who you ask) are registered at this Facility. Where are the rest of the 100,000+ Veterans on Long Island getting their health care, and why aren’t they subscribing to the VA Medical Center? One visit through these “hallowed halls” will answer that question. It takes a Veteran with a high degree of intestinal fortitude to drive by the Guard Shack and into this medical campus seeking medical care. The very first thing they see are two five-story buildings ringed with chain-link fencing, roofs that look like Swiss cheese, and have the appearance of buildings about to fall down on their own. These two particular buildings have been left to decay for almost ten years, while the string of reasons and excuses of why they aren’t being torn down flow from the Director’s office. Again, what’s the problem here? Is there some hidden agenda that is benefiting those at the top? Appearance and perception is everything! Suffice it to say the Veteran in/out patients don’t want to “drink the Kool-Aide” anymore; they want action so that the medical and mental health care they were promised gets delivered properly.
The buildings that must come down:
#1 & #2              the two originals with fencing around them, already condemned
#5                      Auditorium
#6                      Environmental Services (kind of ironic, eh?), Chaplains, Neurology,        Nutrition, Psychiatry, Psychology, Recreational Therapy
#7                      Department offices: Orthopedics, Podiatry, Infectious Control, Employee Education
#9                      Community Relations, Mail Room, Veterans Service Org.’s (mainly    DAV), Volunteer Services
#10                    Management offices: Business, EEO, Engineering, Executive
#11                    Beacon House Domiciliary
#12                    Library, IT
#17,18,37,         Research, affiliated with Stony Brook        
61, 62                State University Medical School       
#63                    Psychology, Vocational Rehab.
#64                    Psychology Clinic, Substance Abuse
#65                    PTSD, Telehealth, Dual Diagnosis (Major new leak and decomposition involving the second story concrete slab floor. It has been open and visible for four weeks with no remediation in sight.) (The plaster outer walls have been exploding with black mold “cancers” for decades.)
#92                    Nursing Home (original)
#36                    Maintenance & Engineering (out buildings)
#88                    Pool & Gymnasium, closed for repairs, opened, closed for repairs,   opened, still cracked and leaking
* There are lesser used and smaller buildings of the same era that need to come                 down also (approx. 6 buildings)
**There are many other offices and clinics in these buildings; I am listing the                  
  major ones. Reference article below.
And, of course, the infamous Building #200 - the main Hospital.

This building is only forty-four years old and, piece by piece, 
the mechanical infrastructure is failing; the Operating Suites’ 
climate control air ducting, the “cooling tower” on the roof, 
and the air conditioning for the basement Radiology and Nuclear 
Medicine departments. What’s next? 
The two buildings on the bottom of 
the the picture to the left are 
condemned and fenced off.
The map on the right shows the total acreage (in red) and
the available acreage for buildings and infrastructure                                                 (in darker red). 
                                                                                                             This map of the Northport VAMC does not 
show all the buildings on the campus.
Saturday, August 6, 2016, © wethepeeps1.com












Sunday, July 10, 2016

VA Conducts Nation's Largest Analysis of Veteran Suicide

VA News Release
07/07/2016 09:01 AM EDT

VA Conducts Nation's Largest Analysis of Veteran Suicide
WASHINGTON — The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) has undertaken the most comprehensive analysis of Veteran suicide rates in the U.S., examining over 55 million Veteran records from 1979 to 2014 from every state in the nation. The effort extends VA's knowledge from the previous report issued in 2010, which examined three million Veteran records from 20 states were available. Based on the data from 2010, VA estimated the number of Veteran deaths by suicide averaged 22 per day. The current analysis indicates that in 2014, an average of 20 Veterans a day died from suicide.
"One Veteran suicide is one too many, and this collaborative effort provides both updated and comprehensive data that allows us to make better informed decisions on how to prevent this national tragedy," said VA Under Secretary for Health, Dr. David J. Shulkin. "We as a nation must focus on bringing the number of Veteran suicides to zero."
The final report will be publicly released later this month. Key findings of the analysis will include: 65% of all Veterans who died from suicide in 2014 were 50 years of age or older.
Veterans accounted for 18% of all deaths from suicide among U.S. adults. This is a decrease from 22% in 2010. Since 2001, U.S. adult civilian suicides increased 23%, while Veteran suicides increased 32% in the same time period. After controlling for age and gender, this makes the risk of suicide 21% greater for Veterans. Since 2001, the rate of suicide among US Veterans who use VA services increased by 8.8%, while the rate of suicide among Veterans who do not use VA services increased by 38.6%.
In the same time period, the rate of suicide among male Veterans who use VA services increased 11%, while the rate of suicide increased 35% among male Veterans who do not use VA services.
In the same time period, the rate of suicide among female Veterans who use VA services increased 4.6%, while the rate of suicide increased 98% among female Veterans who do not use VA services.
Please also see our Suicide Prevention Fact Sheet at the following link: http://www.va.gov/opa/publications/factsheets/Suicide Prevention Fact Sheet New VA Stats 070616 1400.pdf
VA is aggressively undertaking a number of new measures to prevent suicide, including: Ensuring same-day access for Veterans with urgent mental health needs at over 1,000 points of care by the end of calendar year 2016. In fiscal year 2015, more than 1.6 million Veterans received mental health treatment from VA, including at over 150 medical centers, 820 community-based outpatient clinics and 300 Vet Centers that provide readjustment counseling. Veterans also enter VA health care through the Veterans Crisis Line, VA staff on college and university campuses, or other outreach points.
Using predictive modeling to determine which Veterans may be at highest risk of suicide, so providers can intervene early. Veterans in the top 0.1% of risk, who have a 43-fold increased risk of death from suicide within a month, can be identified before clinical signs of suicide are evident in order to save lives before a crisis occurs.
Expanding tele-mental health care by establishing four new regional tele-mental health hubs across the VA healthcare system.

Hiring over 60 new crisis intervention responders for the Veterans Crisis Line. Each responder receives intensive training on a wide variety of topics in crisis intervention, substance use disorders, screening, brief intervention, and referral to treatment.

Statement by Secretary of Veterans Affairs Robert A. McDonald on the Commission on Care Report

From The VA Office of Public and Intergovernmental Affairs
07/06/2016 7 7; 74 AM EDT


WASHINGTON - Today, Secretary of Veterans Affairs Robert A. McDonald released the following statement on the Commission on Care final report. The report is available here.
"On behalf of the Nation's 22 million Veterans and the Department of Veterans Affairs, I thank the members of the Commission on Care for their hard work over the past year. The Commission has produced a wide-ranging set of recommendations on reforming the Veterans Health Administration, and VA looks forward to reviewing and considering these recommendations as we ensure that we remain true to our mission to serve and honor the men and women who are America's Veterans.
"While we will examine the report closely over the coming weeks and respond in a more detailed fashion, I am pleased to see that many of their recommendations are in line with our MyVA efforts to transform the VA into a Veteran-centric organization. Necessary transformational progress has been under way for the past two years, increasing access to health care and improving the Veteran experience of VA. This past March, VA set a new record for completed appointments: 5.3 million inside VA, 730,000 more than in March 2014. We also issued twice as many authorizations for care in the community than in March 2014. Clinical workload is up 11 percent in the past two years. Nearly 97 percent of appointments are now completed within 30 days of the Veteran's preferred date; 22 percent are same-day appointments; average wait times are five days for primary care, six days for specialty care, and two days for mental health care. Nearly 90 percent of Veterans surveyed say they are "satisfied or completely satisfied" with the timeliness of their appointments. "However, until all Veterans say they are satisfied, I won't be satisfied. Nobody at VA will be satisfied. But our progress so far proves that VA's current leadership, direction, and momentum can produce the necessary transformation, as VA has already demonstrated in reducing the backlog of disability compensation claims by 90 percent since 2013.
"We know we can't complete the job without help from our partners. For that reason, I look forward to continuing to work with Congress, Veteran advocates, and Veterans themselves to identify further ways to improve VA.
"There are some things that can be done right now to help us continue our progress. Congress must act on our proposals to consolidate our Community Care programs, modernize and reform the claims appeals process, and pass the bi-partisan Veterans First Act. The window of opportunity is closing fast, but if Congress acts before leaving town this month, 2016 will be the year the nation turned the corner for Veterans.
"In the meantime, as we review the recommendations of the Commission, we will continue to look for other ways to build on the progress we've made to date and ensure we are doing everything possible to faithfully serve those who have served this country."

http://www.va.gov/opa/pressrel/pressrelease.cfm?id=2800

To: The New York Times Editorial Board

Dear Editorial Board,
I read, with great interest, your “Opinion Page” Editorial from July 7, 2016: “Heal the V.A. (But First, Do No Harm)”. I was directed to your Article through the Vietnam Veterans of America’s newsletter (via email). As a consumer of the Veterans Health Administration’s (V.H.A.) product, I found it refreshing that someone in the mainstream Press is finally starting to get to the root problems in the Department of Veterans Affairs. 
For the past six years, I have been attempting to come up with a solution to these problems in order to keep the V.A. alive and well. The purpose this Agency serves for Veterans is one to be thoroughly understood before a “fix” can ever be concocted and implemented. It may be difficult for a non-Veteran to fully understand why the V.A. needs to exist. The answer to this question comes best from a Veteran, and not from a bureaucrat or bean counter.
The V.A., especially the V.H.A., is sacred ground when it comes to the Medical and Mental Health needs of Veterans. There is a pervasive feeling that, once having served in the Military, there is little in the way of understanding between Veterans, civilians, and the private medical/mental health sector. Veterans feel more at ease in a setting filled with other Veterans (people who “get” them).
From my perspective, a bottom up look at fixing the V.A. is the only appropriate avenue of approach. Top management problems in this bureaucracy are only symptoms. The root causes lie in the very structure of this behemoth. Secretary Bob McDonald and his Staff are working with a structure from the 1930’s and trying to utilize 21st Century protocols and regimens. It’s a little like trying to mix oil and water. To truly change the V.A. toward the best interests of our Veterans, one needs to change the antiquated structure that leads to a culture of arrogance, indifference, abuse, inefficiency, and chaos.
Unfortunately, Congress does not have twenty years to attempt a transformation of this system. Best practices would dictate the immediate assembly of qualified Hospital Administrators to reconfigure the parts that currently exist and add, or subtract, parts where necessary. It may also help to include a working Veterans Advisory group that mirrors the common U.S. Military Veteran. In his testimony to the Congressional Commission on Care, Secretary Johnson admitted; “We know we can’t complete the job without help from our partners. For that reason, I look forward to continuing to work with Congress, Veteran advocates, and Veterans themselves to identify further ways to improve the VA.”[1] Why not get started right now?